U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) is implementing a significant overhaul of Form I-129, Petition for a Nonimmigrant Worker, starting January 17, 2025. This form, central to employment-based immigration, is the foundation for visas like H-1B, L-1, and O-1. The upcoming changes will reshape how employers sponsor foreign workers, introducing stricter documentation requirements and compliance measures.
Combined with historical precedents and the current political landscape, these changes could have profound implications for businesses and foreign workers. Understanding the context, both past and present, is critical to navigating what’s ahead.
What’s Changing in 2025
The new form is longer (38 pages) and requires more detailed information in a few key areas:
- Proof of Employer Control: Employers must show they have control over employees, especially those working off-site at client locations. This means providing documentation like employment contracts and performance reviews to prove the employer-employee relationship.
- Third-Party Worksite Details: For employees working at client sites, employers must provide detailed itineraries, client agreements, and supervision documentation. This helps ensure that the employer is actively involved in the employee’s work, even if it’s not performed at the employer’s own location.
- Wage and Benefit Information: Employers must provide detailed information about wages and benefits, including location-specific wage rates, benefits consistency across different roles, and detailed payment structures. This helps ensure that foreign workers are paid fairly and receive the benefits they are entitled to.
These updates go beyond mere paperwork. They represent a policy shift aimed at tightening compliance, increasing transparency, and enhancing worker protections—but at the cost of added complexity for employers and workers alike.
We’ve guided employers through every major immigration shift, and this one is no different. Simplify your immigration program with Boundless. Learn more.
What History Tells Us
The last significant overhaul of employment-based immigration policies occurred during the Trump administration (2017–2020). While there was no single legislative reform, a series of executive actions and policy changes dramatically altered how USCIS processed petitions. These included:
- Buy American, Hire American (BAHA): Increased scrutiny of H-1B and other employment-based visas.
- Higher RFE rates: Spiked to 60% in FY2019, targeting employer-employee relationships and wage compliance.
- Longer processing times: H-1B petitions stretched from 3-4 months to 6-8 months.
- Increased denials: Rates tripled for H-1B petitions, rising from 6% in FY2015 to 21% in FY2019.
These changes disrupted hiring cycles, increased costs, and forced companies to rethink their reliance on foreign talent. The 2025 revisions to Form I-129 mirror many of the same high-scrutiny areas but go further by embedding these requirements into the form itself.
Projected Impacts of the 2025 Overhaul
Processing Times Will Go Up
- Standard processing could extend to 8-12 months, up from 4-6 months.
- Premium processing may struggle to maintain its 15-day guarantee, with RFEs likely causing clock stoppages.
RFEs Will Spike
- Third-party placements: RFE rates could be as high as 70-80% due to new documentation standards.
- Direct employment cases: Could be as high as 50-60%.
- Small businesses: Even higher scrutiny, particularly for newer employers or those with limited resources.
Why These High RFE Projections Are Plausible
Historical peaks were already high. In FY2019, USCIS hit a 60% RFE rate for H-1B petitions, driven by stricter scrutiny of employer-employee relationships, third-party placements, and specialty occupations. Denials often followed RFEs, with the H-1B denial rate tripling to 21% during the same period.
More RFEs? Longer waits? Not with us by your side. Start your filing with Boundless today. Let’s talk.
How These Changes Could Impact Employers
Operational Adjustments
Employers should overhaul their immigration workflows to meet the new requirements before the new rules go into effect:
- Start earlier: Begin petition processes 12-18 months before the intended start date.
- Build flexibility: Create contingency plans for critical roles and adjust project timelines to account for delays.
- Expand compliance efforts: Dedicate more resources to tracking documentation and preparing for RFEs.
Cost Implications
Organizations should prepare for rising expenses:
- Legal fees: More complex filings could require additional legal expertise.
- Compliance systems: Investment in tools for documentation management and tracking.
- RFE responses: Increased frequency of RFEs will require resources to gather evidence and respond promptly.
Industry-Specific Challenges
- Technology and Consulting: Stricter third-party placement rules could disrupt business models reliant on H-1B workers.
- Small Businesses: Limited resources will make it harder for smaller employers to comply, reducing their ability to compete for international talent.
How These Changes Could Impact Foreign Workers
For international workers, the revised Form I-129 introduces new challenges:
- Improved transparency: The changes aim to provide clearer information about wages, benefits, and job duties, offering some protection against exploitation.
- Delays in employment: Lengthened processing times could postpone start dates, creating uncertainty.
- Status risks: Prolonged adjudication may increase the risk of visa status gaps.
Lessons From the Past
Looking at the impacts of Trump-era policies provides a roadmap for what to expect:
- Doubling of Processing Times:
- The complexity of BAHA-driven policies caused significant delays in petition adjudications. The expanded Form I-129 is likely to have a similar effect.
- Increased Costs:
- Employers incurred higher costs due to RFEs, legal consultations, and compliance adjustments. These costs will rise again under the 2025 changes.
- Economic Implications:
- The disruptions led to some companies offshoring operations or abandoning certain projects altogether. The stricter requirements could result in a similar shift, particularly for businesses with less capacity to absorb the costs.
Preparing for 2025
For Employers
To navigate these changes, employers must act now:
- Audit Systems: Review current compliance processes and identify gaps.
- Update Documentation: Train HR teams on new standards and revise internal workflows.
- Engage Experts: Partner with immigration attorneys to manage the complexities of the new form.
- Plan for Delays: Build longer lead times into hiring cycles and project planning.
For Workers
Workers can protect themselves by:
- Staying informed: Understand the new requirements and how they affect your visa category.
- Maintaining records: Keep detailed documentation of your employment history and immigration filings.
- Proactive planning: Work closely with your employer to ensure early and complete petition submissions.
The Bigger Picture: Risks to U.S. Competitiveness
The 2025 changes raise serious concerns about U.S. competitiveness in the global talent market:
- Talent loss: Lengthy delays and high costs may push skilled workers toward more immigration-friendly countries.
- Offshoring: Companies may relocate operations overseas to bypass U.S. immigration hurdles.
- Innovation risks: Startups and growth companies reliant on foreign talent could struggle to stay competitive.
- Industry disruption: Sectors like tech and agriculture, which depend on nonimmigrant workers, may face structural shifts.
The Bottom Line
The Form I-129 overhaul represents the most significant administrative shift in employment-based immigration since the Trump administration. These changes will increase processing times, costs, and scrutiny, requiring businesses and workers to adapt quickly. Organizations that start preparing now—auditing systems, strengthening documentation, and building contingency plans—will be best positioned to navigate the challenges ahead.